Why doesn’t “ask what the other would say” give a direct yes to the safe door?

I’m stuck on the classic two-guards, two-doors puzzle. One guard always tells the truth, the other always lies. One door is safe, one is deadly. I can ask one yes/no question to one guard. I keep thinking the question “Would the other guard say that Door 1 is safe?” should work without any final inversion: I expect a yes to mean safe, and a no to mean unsafe.

My assumption is that there are effectively two negations here (the liar’s behavior and the reference to the other guard’s statement), so they should cancel out. But when I test simple cases in my head, I get inconsistent results depending on which guard I ask. For example, if Door 1 is actually safe and I happen to ask the liar “Would the other guard say that Door 1 is safe?”, I’m expecting some kind of cancellation. Instead, I seem to get that the liar would answer no, which would make me reject the safe door. If I ask the truth-teller the same question, I feel like I should get yes, which would mean the guards would give different answers to the same question, which also seems wrong.

I’m clearly mixing up something about how the liar flips the whole compound statement versus the inner reference to what the other guard would say. Is there a clean way to phrase a single yes/no question so that I don’t have to invert the answer at the end? Or is the inversion unavoidable here, and if so, why doesn’t the “two negatives cancel” idea apply?

Any help appreciated!

One Response

  1. Your hunch is close, but “Would the other guard say Door 1 is safe?” always flips the truth of “Door 1 is safe,” no matter whom you ask-so you inevitably need to invert the answer. Here’s why: if Door 1 is safe, the truth-teller knows the other guard (the liar) would say “no,” so the truth-teller answers “no”; if you ask the liar, he knows the truth-teller would say “yes,” so he lies and answers “no” again. In both cases, you get “no” when the door is safe, and “yes” when it isn’t. The “two negatives cancel” hope fails because the inner reference to the other guard already bakes in a flip relative to the actual safety, and the liar’s flip doesn’t undo that-it just lands you back at the same inversion. If you want a question that gives a direct “yes means safe,” use a biconditional that aligns their behaviors: ask, “Is Door 1 safe if and only if you are the truth-teller?” The truth-teller evaluates this as “Door 1 is safe,” and the liar evaluates “Door 1 is not safe” but must lie about it-so both answer “yes” exactly when the door is safe. I remember finally “getting” this by scribbling T/L faces on coins at a café; the biconditional felt like snapping two puzzle pieces together.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Join Our Community

Ready to make maths more enjoyable, accessible, and fun? Join a friendly community where you can explore puzzles, ask questions, track your progress, and learn at your own pace.

By becoming a member, you unlock:

  • Access to all community puzzles
  • The Forum for asking and answering questions
  • Your personal dashboard with points & achievements
  • A supportive space built for every level of learner
  • New features and updates as the Hub grows