How do I properly compare a cash price to a monthly plan with monthly interest?

I’m revising my financial maths fundamentals and I’m stuck on how to reason about a simple buy-now vs finance choice.

Example: A laptop has a list price of $1,080. Option A: pay cash today and get a $50 discount, so $1,030 now. Option B: $0 down, pay $95 per month for 12 months, plus a $30 setup fee, with 1.8% interest per month on the outstanding balance.

I know I should be careful with time value of money, but I’m not sure how to set this up cleanly. My instinct is to compare present values, but I keep getting lost. One (probably wrong) thing I tried was: total payments are 95×12 = 1,140; add the $30 fee to get 1,170; then I tacked on 1.8%×12 = 21.6% to get about 1,170×1.216 ≈ 1,423. That feels obviously off, because I treated the whole amount as if it sat there for the full year. I also wrote a bogus formula PV = (95×12)/(1 + 0.018×12), which I’m pretty sure is not how discounting works.

Analogy-wise, I’m thinking the finance plan is like a bath that is draining (my repayments) while a tap adds a small percentage flow (interest) each minute. I keep calculating as if the bath were full the whole time.

How should I reason about this properly? Do I discount each of the 12 payments at 1.8% per month back to today and then compare to $1,030? Or should I convert 1.8% monthly to an effective annual rate first and do it some other way? Where exactly does the $30 fee fit-in the present value as an upfront cost, or spread over the payments? I’d appreciate a clear chain of steps. I’m trying to strengthen the basics, and I’d like to understand precisely why my “add 21.6% to the total” approach fails.

3 Responses

  1. Here’s a clean way to think about it: list out the actual cash flows and discount each one back to today at a consistent monthly rate. There’s no need to convert to an annual rate unless you want an annualized headline figure; keeping everything in months avoids timing mistakes. The $30 setup fee should be placed at the time it’s actually charged (if it’s due today, treat it as an upfront cash flow; if it’s added to the first bill, discount it by one month). Your “add 21.6% to the total” idea breaks because interest is charged only on the remaining balance each month, not the full amount for the full year-payments steadily shrink the balance. Tiny example: borrow $100 for two months at 1%/month and repay $50 each month; interest is 1% of $100 in month 1 ($1) and 1% of $50 in month 2 ($0.50), totaling $1.50, not $2.00.

    Let me assume the $95 is the total monthly instalment (i.e., it already includes interest), with 12 equal payments, and the setup fee is paid at signing. Then the present value of the plan is the PV of a 12-month annuity discounted at 1.8%/month, plus the fee. That annuity PV is 95 × [(1 − (1.018)^−12) / 0.018] ≈ 95 × 10.712 ≈ $1,017.6. Add the $30 fee (upfront) to get about $1,047.6 today; if the fee is added to the first bill instead, discount it one month to $30/1.018 ≈ $29.5 and the total PV is about $1,047.1. Compared to paying $1,030 cash today, the cash option is cheaper by roughly $17–$18. (As a quick sense check, $95/month for 12 months at 1.8%/month can only finance about $1,018 today, so it wouldn’t fully cover a $1,080 item unless the store is subsidizing or some detail differs.)

    Two small clarifications you can check with the seller: (i) is the $95 “including interest” (standard amortized payment) or “plus interest” each month? If it’s “$95 toward principal plus interest,” then at 1.8%/month the PV of the 12 payments equals the sticker $1,080 (and adding the $30 fee makes it effectively $1,110 today), which is clearly worse than $1,030 cash. (ii) exactly when is the $30 fee charged? For more background on discounting equal payments and why timing matters, this Khan Academy piece on present value of annuities is helpful: https://www.khanacademy.org/economics-finance-domain/core-finance/interest-tutorial/annuities/v/present-value-of-annuities.

  2. Discount the exact monthly cash flows at the monthly rate and compare to the $1,030 today: take the $30 fee as time-0, then PV_finance = 30 + sum over k=1..12 of [95 + 0.018×(1080 − 95×(k−1))]/(1.018)^k, and whichever PV is lower wins (if the $30 is financed instead, just add it into the first month’s numerator). I used to just slap 21.6% onto the total too, but a tutor’s “shrinking bathtub” analogy finally made me see you have to discount each smaller month’s splash on its own.

  3. Don’t slap 21.6% onto the whole tab – interest hits the shrinking balance, not a full bathtub all year. Treat the plan as a plain amortizing loan at 1.8% per month with a fixed $95 payment for 12 months. The payment implies a financed principal of about 95 × [1 − (1.018)^(−12)] / 0.018 ≈ 1,016 today; if the $30 setup fee is paid now, that makes the plan’s present cost roughly 1,046 at the same monthly rate. Compare that to the cash option at 1,030 today: cash is cheaper by around 16 bucks. Quick example to see the “draining tub”: start at 1,016; first month interest is 1.8% of that, about 18.3, so from your $95 you only knock about 76.7 off principal, leaving roughly 939; next month interest is smaller, and so on – hence why “add 21.6% to the total” overshoots. If you like annualizing, 1.8% monthly compounding is roughly 24% a year, and tossing in the $30 fee pushes the true APR higher; saying “about 21.6% APR” from 1.8 × 12 is a rough-and-ready shortcut that’s kind of fine for a one-year eyeball, but it doesn’t do present value correctly. If you want to be fussy, discount each of the 12 ninety‑fives back at whatever your own monthly opportunity rate is and add the $30 at time zero; a sloppy but quick hack is to divide the 1,140 total payments by about 1 plus your monthly rate times 6 (pretend the cash flows land mid‑year), which won’t be exact but gets you in the ballpark. If the $30 fee is rolled into the balance instead of paid upfront, it also accrues interest, so the plan gets a bit worse than the numbers above.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Join Our Community

Ready to make maths more enjoyable, accessible, and fun? Join a friendly community where you can explore puzzles, ask questions, track your progress, and learn at your own pace.

By becoming a member, you unlock:

  • Access to all community puzzles
  • The Forum for asking and answering questions
  • Your personal dashboard with points & achievements
  • A supportive space built for every level of learner
  • New features and updates as the Hub grows